Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03 Review & Swatches


by Ayushi Jindal


Hey pretty ladies!

This happens to be my first review on Wise She and I promise that I’ll give you wise reviews always. I am quite excited to write my first article here 🙂 So the product I am reviewing is this eye pencil from Deborah. This was a part of my huge haul of Deborah pencils 🙂 So let’s see how it is..


Deborah Milano ExtraEyePencil 03

Price and Quantity: INR 450/- for 24m.You can buy this from Flipkart here

Product Description: The latest plastic pencil enclosing an innovative long-wearing waterproof formula. With a consistency that glides on instantly and effortlessly, and a texture that is amazingly comfortable. Ophthalmologist tested.

Packaging: It is a typical pencil packaging, nothing extra-ordinary about it. There isn’t any inbuilt sharpener. You have to sharp it every time you use it for a precise application.


Deborah Milano Waterproof eyepencil 03

My experience with Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03:

This was my first eye pencil from Deborah and I must say I am impressed with the quality and price. This pencil performs a lot better than some expensive pencils. The texture is very creamy and smooth and it glides on effortlessly on my lids. As it is waterline safe and waterproof so I applied it on my waterline and lower lash line as well. Well nothing really stays on my waterline but it did for 2-3 hours and after that I was left with a beautiful hint of the color and I was happy with that.

I am absolutely glad that it didn’t gave me those raccoon eyes, that is the problem that I face with most of the eye pencils despite the fact that I don’t have oily lids.


Deborah ExtraEyePencil 03

The shade is beautiful mehendi green and will suit almost every eye color and skin tone and yes goes amazingly well with Indian Skin tones. What else do we need 😉

The color did fade to some extent after 2-3 hours and it wasn’t looking that fresh as it did at the time of application but I don’t mind it.

The pencil can be used to create beautiful smokey eyes if it is smudged instantly after application.


Deborah Milano ExtraEyePencil 03 swatch

All and all I am in love with this eye pencil 🙂 Texture, Color, Staying Power everything is fabulous. And it came off easily with my Lancome Bi-Facil Remover.

Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03

Let’s sum up the Pros and Cons

What I like about Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03:

  • Available in various shades.
  • Waterproof.
  • Decently priced for the results it gives.
  • Beautiful Mehndi Green shade to suit almost every skin tone.
  • Intense color pay off.
  • Provides a natural look.
  • Doesn’t smudge.
  • Didn’t gave me raccoon eyes :-P.
  • No fragrance.
  • Available easily.
  • Comes off easily with a Make-up Remover.
  • Creamy and smooth texture.

What I don’t like about Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03:

  • A lot of product is wasted in sharpening.
  • Doesn’t stays fresh for a long time.

Do I recommend this Product?

Definitely yes, I am looking forward to buy more shades in it.

Rating: 4.5/5

Have you tried Deborah Milano Extra Eye Pencil 03 Review & Swatches?

You might also like reading these:-



  1. Welcome to this lovely place Ayushi…!!…
    nice review…not a fan of shimmery eye pencils, but it looks sooo good on you…!!! pretty EOTD..

  2. hey Sorry girlies I wasn’t able to reply you all today.. It was my Birthday.. Thank you all for your lovely feedback 🙂 🙂


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here