ELF All Over Color Stick Toasted Review & Swatches


ELF Essential All Over Colour Stick in Toasted


Hey there!

Contouring and highlighting techniques have been making the rounds of beauty blogs in recent times due to the stress on bone structure. Flawlessly high cheekbones, straight noses, angular jawlines and dewy complexions have never been more sought after.


ELF All Over Stick Toasted


While these techniques look incredible if employed correctly, they have the potential of looking extremely garish and OTT.  While everyday contouring is a little taxing, a minute amount of highlighting can be done during winters to make the skin look less dehydrated and more supple. But most drugstore highlighting products in the Indian market are just silver shimmer that WILL look over the top during the day. So I set out to look for an inexpensive highlighting product in my favourite brand, read on to see if it met my standards.

Price: $1

About ELF All Over Color Stick:

This 3-in-1 Color Stick adds a beautiful glow to your eyes, lips, or face! Get gorgeous color that illuminates and instantly conditions skin for fresh and natural color all day long. Blend anywhere you would like to highlight and brighten like your cheeks and brow bones.

Twist stick and apply liberally to face, eyes and/or lips.


ELF Stick Toasted


Ingredients: Aqua(Water), Isopropyl Myristate, Octyl Isopalmitate, Ceresin Wax, Microcrystalline Wax (Cera Microcristallina), Sorbitol, Mica, Titanium Dioxide (CI 77891), Iron Oxides (CI 77491 , CI 77492 , CI 77499), Red No.6 Lake (CI 15850)

Quantity :4 grams


ELF AllOverStick Toasted


My take on ELF All Over Color Stick Toasted:

While I love e.l.f. Cosmetics due to their business practices and pricing strategy I’ll be the first to admit that their products can be a hit or miss, especially in the Essential line. So if you want to order anything from e.l.f. be sure to research the product reviews religiously to find out if the product is worth it, because even a dollar counts sometimes. 😛


ELF Toasted All Over Stick


This product isn’t a hit but it isn’t a miss either. It is a very versatile product that can be used as a highlighter with a little clever blending, an effortless body shimmer or even as a hair glitter for mahogany hair. The colour is a beautiful warm bronze that would look perfect on dusky skinned beauties and can lend a warmth to the complexion of cool toned ladies.

While this product provides one stroke opacity which looks brilliant in swatches it doesn’t quite translate in the same way on the face. This is because blending this product is a bit problematic. If swiped on, it has a very warm sheen but if one tries to blend it too much it just disintegrates to a bronze glitter and one needs to start over or risk looking like a Disco Era reject. But if one applies this product correctly with minimal blending, it looks incredible.


ELF All Over Stick Toasted swatch


Another problem is it’s lasting power, it lasts a mere 2-3 hours on my dry skin, obviously using a decent primer and setting powder improves its longevity but that is a separate scenario. It also has this very strange orange smell that I find very disconcerting but then again, I have a very sensitive nose so most people might not find this a problem.


ELF All Over Stick Toasted swatches


What I like about ELF All Over Color Stick Toasted:

  • Inexpensive
  • Shade collection
  • Versatile
  • Long lasting
  • Weightless
  • e.l.f. are not tested on animals
  • One stroke opacity
  • Perfect highlighting colour for dark skinned beauties
  • Travel safe packaging
  • Beautiful shimmer

What I don’t like about ELF All Over Color Stick Toasted:

  • Can look OTT if not used properly
  • Unhygienic
  • Longevity leaves a lot to be desired
  • Contains parabens
  • Unavailability in India
  • Strong chemical scent
  • Cheap packaging

Would I repurchase? Nope! I’ll certainly try something else.

Would I recommend it to friends? At a dollar? It’s worth the risk. 😛

Rating: 3.5/5

Have you tried ELF All Over Color Stick Toasted ?

You might also like reading these:-


  1. I am not very much into highlighting but your swatch makes me think to try doing with this product and that too with a steal price..! nice review Nivanya 🙂

  2. What a detailed and insightful review nivanya. I am just starting out to contouring and j am definitely going to land up starring opposite mithun in one of his movies if I use this. Thanks for the warning…

  3. I’m going crazy looking for a dupe (the price doesn’t matter). This shade is perfection for my skin tone, but it is hard to blend. Any suggestions? Please share!


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here